Skip to content
Blue graphic reading Is Butter Really Worse Than Seed Oils? Breaking Down the Latest Study in JAMA Internal Medicine

Is Butter Really Worse Than Seed Oils?

A recent study published in JAMA Internal Medicine is making headlines—and waves—by claiming that butter is worse for you than plant-based seed oils. If you’re part of or following the Make America Healthy Again (MAHA) movement, this likely raised more than a few eyebrows.

Let’s take a closer look at what this study really says, what its limitations are, and why it may do more harm than good in advancing meaningful conversations around nutrition and health.

What the Study Claims

This research looked at data from over 500,000 participants in the NIH-AARP Diet and Health Study. The conclusion? Eating more butter was associated with higher risk of death, while eating more plant-based oils was associated with lower mortality risk.

The authors recommend replacing butter with plant oils to improve long-term health.


What’s the Problem?

This might sound compelling—after all, it’s in a prestigious journal—but there are three major issues that compromise the validity and interpretation of this study.

1. They Don’t Actually Know How Much Butter People Ate

  • Participants were given a food frequency questionnaire (FFQ)—basically, a survey asking how often they ate butter (e.g., “2–3 times a week”).  
  • Eating a croissant with a hint of butter is treated the same as sautéing your dinner in half a stick.
  • And it turns out, butter has one of the lowest correlations between frequency and actual intake in FFQ validation studies. Translation? The data is shaky at best.

2. They Grouped Olive Oil With Seed Oils

  • The study lumped olive oil, canola oil, and seed oils (like soybean, corn, safflower) into one “plant-based oils” category.
  • That’s a huge problem because olive oil—especially extra virgin—is widely regarded as beneficial across nearly all dietary camps, including those in MaHA.
  • Mixing it with heavily processed seed oils masks the real driver of the observed benefits.

This feels like stacking the deck to support a desired conclusion.

3. Confounding Lifestyle Differences

  • People who reported eating more butter may have very different lifestyles compared to those who preferred plant-based oils.
  • Factors like income, physical activity, healthcare access, and other diet choices may influence outcomes far more than the butter itself.
  • Even with statistical adjustments, residual confounding is a persistent flaw in this kind of research.

4. The Type of Butter Wasn’t Recorded

  • The nutrient and toxin profiles vary drastically from raw, grass-fed butter to chemical-laden, conventional “butter”.

Is It Credible Science?

This is a classic case of observational nutritional epidemiology—research that can suggest associations but cannot prove cause and effect.

  • These types of studies are notoriously weak and prone to bias.
  • Publishing this kind of data in a prestigious journal like JAMA gives it an outsized sense of credibility, despite its shaky foundations.

Is There a Bigger Agenda?

Some critics argue this study is less about science and more about pushing back against alternative health narratives—like those promoted by Make America Healthy Again (MAHA) and public figures such as RFK Jr.

Whether or not that’s true, what’s clear is that using low-credibility science to fight cultural or political battles only deepens public mistrust and division.

What Can You Take Away From This?

  • Don’t let sensational headlines dictate your health decisions.
  • Observational studies can be helpful, but they shouldn’t override traditional, nutrient-dense approaches to eating.
  • Whole-food cooking methods—using olive oil, ghee, butter, or animal fats—may be a better guide than politically polarized research.

🧭 Reflect On This

Are your cooking fat choices based on real food principles, cultural tradition, and personal experience—or are they shaped by ever-shifting headlines and institutional biases?

P.S. This article is for educational purposes only and is not intended as medical advice. Please consult your trusted healthcare provider or functional medicine practitioner to determine what’s best for your individual needs.

Praise From Our Clients

Don't Wait Until Your Health Crisis Forces You to Act

You don't have to hit rock bottom to start healing. You don't have to accept feeling terrible as your new normal. You deserve answers, you deserve to be heard, and you deserve healthcare that actually works. Request your free discovery call today and take the first step toward the vibrant, energized life you were meant to live.